"Argentina believes that it is not racist, because Argentina believes that there are no black people. In Argentina there are no black people, that is a problem of Brazil." — Carlos Menem, then president of Argentina, 1996Carlos Saúl Menem, president of Argentina between 1989 and 1999, uttered the phrase that synthesizes the myth of "white Argentina" during an official ceremony in 1996.
The former president's phrase, rescued by a report by Deutsche Welle (DW Español) entitled "How Argentina erased its black and indigenous history", is not an isolated provocation. It is, according to historians and anthropologists quoted by the German media, the synthesis of a founding myth that the Argentine State deliberately built for more than a century.
The DW video draws a sharp line between Argentina's self-image—"the most European country in South America," "Italians who speak Spanish"—and a historical reality of systematic racial invisibility. The evidence is compelling:
1588 First enslaved Africans arrived in Argentina 200,000+ Africans enslaved between the sixteenth and nineteenth centuries ~33% Population of African descent in 1778 <1% Identify as Afro-descendant in 2022The question DW raises is inevitable: where did they go?
How Argentina erased its black and indigenous history
II Whitening: State Policy
The DW report argues that conventional explanations – disproportionate recruitment of black people in the wars of independence and a devastating yellow fever epidemic in 1871 – are insufficient. Historians cited by the German media point to a more determining factor: a deliberate policy of invisibilization promoted by the Argentine state itself.
Ethnic whitening was an explicit policy that:
- He encouraged intermarriage as a mechanism of racial dilution.
- He promoted subsidized mass immigration: between 1850 and 1950, approximately 7 million immigrants, mainly from Spain and Italy, arrived in the country with state support.
- It systematically excluded Black and Indigenous people from public records, erasing them from the census, official documents, and the national narrative.
As DW points out, this "suppression on paper" led to acts of explicit violence:
14,000 Indians killed in the Conquest of the Desert (1878-1885) 400-500 People massacred in Napalpí (1924) — crime against humanity in 2022Even the country's most famous export product—beef—is linked to this history of exclusion: the large cattle ranches were built on land stripped from indigenous communities, and the gauchos—a mythical figure of Argentinianness—were largely Afro-descendants whose presence was deliberately omitted from the national epic.
III The Crack That Won't Close: Domestic Policy in 2026
While the discussion on Argentine identity occupies historians and activists, the country's political situation is going through one of its most intricate moments since the inauguration of Javier Milei in December 2023.
The ruling party: internal elections in Casa Rosada
As reported by Clarín, Infobae and La Nación, Milei's government is facing growing internal tension between two central figures in the presidential circle:
- Karina Milei, sister of the president and secretary general of the Presidency, considered the guardian of access to the president and the political strategist of the ruling party.
- Santiago Caputo, star advisor and brain of government communication, architect of the libertarian narrative on social networks.
The dispute, which the Argentine media describe as a "cold war" in Casa Rosada, has concrete implications: who controls the lists of candidates, who manages the relationship with the governors and, above all, who defines the electoral strategy for the 2025 legislative elections and Milei's possible reelection.
The opposition front: Kirchnerism in redefinition
On the other side of the rift, Peronism-Kirchnerism is going through its own tension. El País (Spain) and Clarín report a growing distance between Cristina Fernández de Kirchner and Axel Kicillof, governor of the province of Buenos Aires, who seeks to consolidate himself as the heir of Kirchnerism but with his own profile.
The dispute over the PASO (Open, Simultaneous and Mandatory Primaries) – which Milei's government promised to eliminate – is the immediate battlefield.
Journalism and public opinion
Poliarquía's ranking of Argentina's most respected journalists—headed by Carlos Pagni—reflects a society eager for in-depth analysis in a hyperpolarized media ecosystem, where every fact is filtered by two irreconcilable narratives.
The Malvinas cause continues to be one of the few points of cross-cutting consensus in Argentine politics, although with nuances depending on the political sign of the government in power.IV World Cup 2026: FIFA and Messi against the world?
But if there is one issue that in 2026 has transcended Argentina's borders and has put the country at the center of the global conversation, it is the refereeing controversy of the World Cup.
The "VARgentina" phenomenon
The term, coined by the international press, summarizes the perception that FIFA has systematically favored the Argentine national team and Lionel Messi in the 2026 World Cup. The controversy escalated to the headlines of the world's main media.
BBC News Mundo published an article titled "2026 World Cup: Are Argentina and Messi Getting Favorable Treatment from FIFA?". talkSPORT published a list of 9 points with circumstantial evidence that point to a pro-Argentina bias, from questionable referee appointments to the commercial factor that Messi represents as the most valuable asset in world football.
FIFA's response
Pierluigi Collina, chairman of the FIFA Referees Committee, categorically denied any favouritism. In statements collected by Reuters, Collina defended the impartiality of the refereeing body and described the accusations as "unfounded". However, media such as The Straits Times (Singapore) and Channel News Asia point out that "even if there is no evidence of conspiracy, the perception of favouritism damages the credibility of the tournament".
The Argentine national team during the 2026 World Cup, in the midst of the refereeing controversy that has marked the tournament.Messi at the center of the hurricane
The figure of Lionel Messi, historically considered untouchable, has been put under scrutiny like never before. Infobae and Clarín, from Argentina, respond by pointing to a "smear campaign" against the world champion team, while El País (Spain) tries a more balanced tone.
Meanwhile, in the streets of Argentina, the passion for the national team is not discussed: crowds at the Obelisk, charter flights crossing the Atlantic and Argentine clubs in every corner of the world.
V The image of Argentina in the mirror
What connects these three axes – the history of racial whitening, the political rift and the World Cup controversy – is the question of Argentine identity and its international projection.
Argentina sees itself as exceptional in Latin America: whiter, more European, more cultured, more soccer-like. That self-image has been built, as DW documents, on centuries of racial erasure. Today, that same narrative of exceptionality fuels both resistance to international criticism of referee favoritism and internal political polarization.
The country that refuses to recognize its racial diversity is the same one that is outraged when the world questions its national team. The Argentina that erased its blacks and indigenous people from public records is the same one that today debates whether the criticisms of the international press are "an anti-Argentine conspiracy."
As DW points out, history is not just the past: it is the mirror in which a nation chooses to look at itself or deny itself.
The Argentine identity, between the self-image of a European exception and a history of racial erasure that the country is just beginning to recognize.Sources
- DW English — "How Argentina Erased Its Black and Indigenous History" (Original video, transcript via faster-whisper)
- BBC News World — "2026 World Cup: Are Argentina and Messi Getting Favorable Treatment from FIFA?"
- Reuters — Statement by Pierluigi Collina (FIFA)
- talkSPORT — "9 reasons why the world thinks FIFA is helping Argentina and Messi"
- The Straits Times / Channel News Asia — Coverage of the VARgentina phenomenon
- Clarín — Internal between Karina Milei and Santiago Caputo
- Infobae — Political analysis of the dispute over the PASO
- La Nación — Tensions between CFK and Axel Kicillof
- El País (Spain) — Analysis of the Argentine political situation
- Poliarquía — Argentina's Most Respected Journalists Ranking 2025-2026




